Stablecoin payment flows and Canadian MSB analysis
Stablecoin payment infrastructure in Canada engages the virtual currency dealer definition under FINTRAC rules, and the analysis turns on custody, role, and fund flow.
Crypto exchange MSB obligations in Canada
Canadian crypto exchanges are required to register as MSBs with FINTRAC and maintain a full AML compliance program — the obligations are specific and the enforcement record is growing.
Cryptocurrency exchanges operating in Canada, or serving Canadian customers, are required to register as money services businesses with FINTRAC. That registration requirement has been in place since 2014 and was expanded in 2021 to include foreign exchanges with Canadian customers. The compliance obligations that follow registration are substantial, and FINTRAC has demonstrated a willingness to examine and penalize exchanges that do not meet them.
The virtual currency dealer definition and exchanges
An entity that exchanges virtual currency for fiat, or one virtual currency for another, is dealing in virtual currency under the PCMLTFA. That definition captures the core activity of cryptocurrency exchanges: facilitating the purchase and sale of virtual currency by users.
The definition also captures related activities. An exchange that holds virtual currency on behalf of users, that transfers virtual currency at user direction, or that provides wallet services alongside exchange functionality is performing multiple forms of virtual currency dealing. Each of those activities independently engages the MSB registration requirement.
Foreign exchanges that direct their services at Canadian customers, accept Canadian customers, or process transactions involving Canadian bank accounts are subject to FINTRAC’s requirements regardless of where the exchange is incorporated. FINTRAC has enforcement history against foreign exchanges that operated in Canada without registration.
What compliance programs look like for exchanges
A compliant AML program for a cryptocurrency exchange includes the same five elements required of all MSBs — written policies, risk assessment, training, ongoing compliance, and record-keeping — with content specific to the exchange’s business model.
The risk assessment for an exchange needs to address the risks associated with the virtual currencies listed on the platform, including privacy coins and tokens with unusual transfer characteristics. It needs to address the customer segments the exchange serves, including retail customers, institutional customers, and high-volume traders. It needs to address the geographic markets from which the exchange accepts customers and the higher-risk jurisdictions among those markets.
Transaction monitoring for an exchange operates across a combination of on-chain data and off-chain account data. The monitoring system needs to assess transaction patterns at the account level, using the exchange’s own customer data, as well as transaction characteristics at the blockchain level, using blockchain analytics tools to identify counterparty risk.
Know-your-client obligations for exchanges require identity verification before account activation, with enhanced due diligence for high-risk customers and high-value transactions. Verification standards for virtual currency dealers include document-based identity verification and, in some circumstances, source of funds documentation.
Banking and processor relationships for exchanges
Banking is a material operational constraint for Canadian cryptocurrency exchanges. Many Canadian banks are reluctant to provide banking services to crypto exchanges, citing money laundering risk and the operational complexity of monitoring crypto-related fiat flows.
Exchanges that operate without a stable Canadian banking relationship face significant operational risk, including the inability to process fiat deposits and withdrawals in Canadian dollars and the inability to maintain the fiat liquidity needed for exchange operations. The banking relationship is not a compliance issue in isolation, but it is closely connected to the compliance program quality that banks assess during onboarding.
Processor relationships for exchanges are subject to similar diligence. Card processors, pre-authorized debit providers, and payment facilitators each conduct their own AML review of exchange customers before providing services.
The securities law intersection
In addition to FINTRAC obligations, Canadian crypto exchanges face potential securities regulation depending on the products they offer. The Canadian Securities Administrators have applied securities law to crypto asset trading platforms, particularly where the platform allows users to trade crypto assets that may be securities or where the platform holds or controls user assets.
The CSA’s guidance and registration actions in this area have evolved significantly since 2021. Exchanges offering spot trading of major cryptocurrencies have faced CSA scrutiny, and several exchanges have registered as restricted dealers or entered into pre-registration undertakings with the CSA. The securities law analysis is separate from and additive to the FINTRAC MSB analysis.
Related topics
Related Posts
View All Posts »Stablecoin infrastructure and regulated activity
Infrastructure providers that enable stablecoin payment flows can engage Canadian MSB registration requirements depending on their role in custody, settlement, and transfer.
Stablecoin settlement and fiat conversion
The points where stablecoins are converted to fiat currency are where Canadian MSB registration analysis concentrates for settlement infrastructure.
Stablecoin treasury products and Canadian AML risk
Companies using stablecoins for treasury operations need to assess whether the activity engaged constitutes dealing in virtual currency under Canadian law.